"II
was wondering if there is any copy of the thesis (or paper) that
Suzuki-roshi wrote on Dogen's Raihai Tokusui. It is an interesting fascicle
to me in particular because Dogen lambastes the custom of excluding women
from the sacred mountain of Mt. Hiei and other discriminating practices.
I thought it would be very interesting to read what Suzuki-roshi's
commentary on this was." - From an email sent in March 2000
DC - I hear Suzuki concentrated on the master disciple
relationship part of the fascicle.
DC Reply: Carl Bielefeldt obtained a copy of Suzuki’s thesis from Komazawa University in
Tokyo in the prior century, and Gil Fronsdal and Carl have been working on
getting it translated as a project of Gil's Sati Foundation I assume. I
remember Gil telling me it was an expensive project. That was maybe 13
years ago. Don't know where it stands now. DC - 2021
Here's the
outline of it got from Gil Fronsdal - reproduced below
Draft of Carl's
1998 excellent talk at Stanford Sati Foundation Shunryu Suzuki
conference on Suzuki's historical and teaching background. It begins
with a discussion of Suzuki's dissertation
Shōbōgenzō raihai tokuzui -
正法眼藏禮拜得髓
I used to hear that Suzuki's thesis was on bowing. That's part of the
name of Raihai Tokusui. I bet he'd rather we read the Dogen than wonder
what he wrote in college.
Here's a translation from the Stanford site - Getting the Marrow by
Doing Obeisance
Translated by Stanley Weinstein
from the White Wind Zen Community - Bowing and Acquiring the Essence
From Crooked Cucumber,
Ch. 3, Higher Education, p. 61
At the late
age of twenty-five, on April 10, 1930, Shunryu graduated from Komazawa
University, second in his class, in Buddhist and Zen philosophy, with a
minor in English. His graduate thesis, written under his academic advisor
and the school's president, Nukariya Kaiten, focused on the relationship
between master and disciple, as discussed by Dogen in an essay of the
Shobogenzo emphasizing submission to the master. (It is called the Raihai
Tokozui, a chapter in which Dogen also forcefully asserts the equality of
women.) In his thesis Shunryu leaned toward Nukariya's "religious
experience" point of view rather than Buddhism as philosophy. Another key
professor whose instruction influenced Shunryu's thesis was Sokuo Eto, an
eminent Shobogenzo scholar who emphasized an open-minded approach to study
integrated with zazen and Buddhist practice. Eto had been a classmate of
So-on's, and they had studied together with Oka Sotan. Like many of
Shunryu's professors, he was also a priest with a temple back home, and,
like Nukariya, he emphasized religion over philosophy, direct experience
over systemization.
Read
the whole chapter |